New York’s right-to-repair bill has major carve-outs for manufacturers

New York’s right-to-repair bill has major carve-outs for manufacturers

New York State was the first state to pass a “right-to-repair” law during the lull between Christmas and New Years. However, some advocates claim that the amended language renders the law useless. The Digital Fair Repair Act, which will take effect July 1, is a law that requires manufacturers to give owners and independent repair shops all the necessary manuals, diagnostics, and diagrams to repair consumer devices.

What devices is the Digital Fair Repair Act applicable to? There are many devices that can be considered “digital electronic equipment” in the Digital Fair Repair Act. There are some exceptions. These include cars, home appliances and medical devices. Enterprise devices used by schools, hospitals, data centers and schools also have to be considered.

This legislation applies only to gadgets made after July 1. It doesn’t require manufacturers or distributors to provide any security unlocking codes necessary to repair a device. These same manufacturers can decline to supply specific components if they feel that “the risk from improper installation increases the risk of injury.”

The majority of these exceptions were added at last minute with Governor Kathy Hochul’s approval. She stated in a statement that they are intended to reduce the risk of security problems and physical harm while making repairs. Advocates such as Louis Rossman, who owns a MacBook repair shop in New York, expressed immediate doubt, arguing that manufacturers would exploit the amendments for their own ends.

Ars Technica reports that representatives from Apple and Microsoft pressed Hochul to make changes. reported Last year. TechNet, an industry association representing tech companies like Amazon, Google, and TechCrunch parent Yahoo!, also passed the bill. The previous version of this bill was supported by many bipartisans and passed the New York state assembly with 147-2 and the Senate with 59-4. However, it remained on the governor’s desk for several months.

“Such changes could limit benefits for school computers, and most products currently being used,” Public Interest Research Groups (a collective of consumer rights organisations) stated. Submitted Engadget released a statement last week. “Even more troubling is that the bill now excludes certain smartphones circuit boards from parts manufacturers are required sell and requires repair shops post unwieldy warranties language.”

Rossman points out, however, that the Digital Fair Repair Act will allow companies like Apple to continue serializing components after a repair. This will prevent independent repairers from repairing devices using spare parts, even genuine parts, as well as preventing them from repairing the device with spare parts. “[The] Manufacturer will tell you that if you have a bad $28 motherboard chip, you need to replace the $745 Motherboard.” He responded in video to the law’s passage.

The Digital Fair Repair Act is one of a number of bills that have been introduced in more than 40 US states recently. It aims to expand repair options for consumer-grade devices. The legislation’s supporters claim that consumers are limited by a lack of documentation and poor access to spare parts, as well as software restrictions. Manufacturers counter that authorized repairs will protect their intellectual property and ensure quality.

President Joe Biden signed last year an executive order requesting that the U.S. Federal Trade Commission ban “anticompetitive restraints on independent repair shops or DIY repairs of your devices and equipment.” In anticipation of new regulations, companies such as Google, Apple and Samsung began offering repair manuals and parts for their products.

Continue reading